Thoughts from the inside 30: being up to the perspective of being a subject of being
Situations happen.
It is a casual fact, so to speak, of living.
What is not given, what shapes everyone's destiny, to put it in Nietzsche's words, is what each person does with what happens to him/her.
A famous quote by Nietzsche introduces the substantial difference between "...being what one has become and becoming what one is..." (1) is also valid in all those life situations that happen, even if it would be desirable for them not to happen.
These are situations in which an individual, that we consider the sole subject of his/her own life, is progressively stripped of his/her subjectivity, till the worst of becoming an object of, and defined by, the violence he/she have endured. Any form of violence, whether occasional or persistent, strips a person of his/her own subjectivity.
The violence, once experienced, design the shape of a trauma. This term, etymologically, implies a rupture or a piercing, which leaves an indelible mark on the victim’s identity, transforming one from the subject of his/her own life into a victim of the violence inflicted by others. The words of Paul Preciado resonate here: “…to be marked by an identity simply means lacking the power to designate one’s own identity position as universal…” (2)
The endured violence demands a meaning that transcends this stripping away of identity, a significant that goes beyond the pain and suffering, especially when such violence occurs within contexts that culturally are supposed to be safe for affection, care, and personal growth, such as families, schools, religious communities, sports, friendships, or couple relationships.
When life imposes violence within one or more of these spheres, the Nietzsche's quote becomes difficult to navigate in either direction; instead, it crystallizes into only one of its possibilities: the individual, having been stripped of their subjectivity by the violence suffered, is left to seek a complex, desperate, and devastating equilibrium, ultimately accepting, as their only path, the reality of “…becoming what one has become…”: namely, a victim.
It's precisely from this position that the request of care arises, along with all the associated implications that confront, and at times overwhelm, the person who receives it.
This is why the delicate nature of care work is so central when dealing with individuals who have endured specific situations, personal histories, or even entire lives consumed by the violence they have suffered.
One often encounters, and occasionally clashes with, stances or movements that, whether consciously or not, seek to "normalize" the event (or the events), a term here to be understood as a "singular plural."
For this reason, I believe it is crucial to reflect on the position of the professional, on how one is expected to inhabit the "place of the supposed knowledge," to use a Lacanian turn of phrase.
To put it more radically, directly, and transparently: to what extent do the analyst’s (or more generally, the professional's) own desire and phantasy occupy the chair toward which a request for care is directed, a request that anticipates an answer, and often a "cure," for the stripping away of subjectivity and the subjugation experienced by the victim?
A first intuitive response points back to what Lacan remarked during a lecture in October 1967 at the Centre Hospitalier du Vintier in Lyon, specifically that it's necessary to have
“(…) psychoanalysts capable of being up to the perspective of being a subject of being” (3)
Indeed, intuitive. Simple and straightforward.
It is so simple and straightforward that it gives rise to a further question: to what extent does "being up to the perspective" in relation to a subject depend on the specific nature of the individual demanding care, and to what extent does it depend on a capacity to meet the challenge regardless of that individual’s particular nature?
We might rephrase this question as follows: how much of "being up to the perspective" relates to the fact of being a subject, or of being subjected, to oneself (to one’s own self-image, ideals, phantasms, to both vulnerable and wounded aspects, as well as to the unconscious), and how much relates to the "other", to the subject of the unconscious?
It is well understood that encountering a demand for care entails opening up spaces for subjectivation, spaces that should be, by their very nature, "unsaturated",so that the person demanding care may discover their own unique and unrepeatable way of unfolding their own subjectivation. This statement of intent represents an approach that virtually everyone acknowledges.
And yet, at times, or perhaps quite often, something else happens.
If we were to use a metaphor and say that reality is the oxygen of life, we would observe a peculiar phenomenon: as we ascend into the realm of stated intentions, reality becomes increasingly rarefied, and when this happens, it is felt immediately in the body: breathing becomes difficult. One is, quite literally, left breathless.
This bodily sensation is frequently encountered when listening to the life stories of those who have experienced violence.
For violence itself, and the narration of violence, takes one’s breath away; it is often felt immediately upon and within the body.
Let us, then, focus first on the true subject of care, who, as we know, is not the psychologist, analyst, or therapist, but rather the person who articulates the need for care.
We might say that this person is our "other", to whom we, in turn, are also an "other." The "other" of the "other", both incidental and symbolic. The "other" to whom the unconscious subject speaks, and through whom they speak.
Paying close attention to this dynamic is essential, as it is whenever facing any transference or countertransference process.
While this is generally true in all contexts, it is especially critical in care work with individuals who have suffered violence, given the implications and reactions it can trigger in those who listen to their stories.
Consequently, when working specifically with individuals who present themselves as “victims,” this essential aspect demands an extra degree of attention.
The underlying reason is clear: if someone demanding care does so from the established identity position of a “victim”, and since a victim is defined by their role as the passive object of a perpetrator (one is always a victim of something or someone), then it follows that the very act of demanding care from this position casts the person receiving the demand of care into the role of the perpetrator, within the framework of the victim’s own phantom.
Given that the dimension of violence, especially when it is repeated and ongoing, tends to slip away from the symbolic, saturated as it is by the "real," this identification also tends to slide into the realm of the "real."
It inevitably becomes a breeding ground for actions and "acting out", behaviors that must be registered, interpreted, and imbued with meaning.
They should not be viewed as isolated acts, nor, even worse, as actions directed toward or against the therapeutic process or the therapist.
Instead, they should be understood for their symbolic value, offering a potential retrospective meaning within a discourse whose only "existential" aspect is a constant, recurring reference to its own patriarchal origins.
This includes verbal aggression, persistent devaluation, and manipulative or seductive behaviors, which can take on a wide variety of forms.
These may manifest in an intellectualized, narcissistic way, for instance, through a demand for reports, statements or declarations that confirms the patient’s compliance. Underlying this is a seductive gesture, implicitly directed at the therapist’s own skill in fostering such compliance. This seductive and manipulative dynamic can even extend into an almost physical, and at times sexualized, dimension, involving allusions or even overt sexual advances toward the therapist.
Other times it can be directed towards alienating and provocative movements, such as the story of situations of violence suffered, or committed, towards third parties, even minors, in a time frame presented as current to solicit alarmism and interventionism of the therapist, when it comes to events which occurred in a historical time, even much earlier.
What often happens is a precise and timely narration of every single detail of the violence suffered, to create a frame that is partly a life-saving movement of de-personalization in an excessively detailed journalistic narrative ("...this is what they did to my body, not to me"...), and which can partly slip into a voyeurism that borders on an involuntary effect of sadistic and perverse enjoyment for the power to horrify the therapist.
Sometimes, more simply, in the involuntary obsessive application of the rules, as in the punctuality to the second of the start of the sessions, or, on the contrary, in the systematic transgression of the basic rules, such as the punctuality of appointments, the late or no notice of canceled sessions, in an exhausting continuous search for verification of not being subjected to the rule of others, and therefore in the constant verification of a non-punishability which is repeated in the concrete field until its elaboration in the symbolic dimension.
The theme of time, which is often manifested as lateness, might trigger an additional effect: it can evoke in the therapist a vague sense of being devalued, as if the time allotted for the session belonged solely to the therapist and were too precious to be 'wasted'. Moreover, by a strange irony, it is often overlooked that when the repressed, and thus the trauma, resurfaces during a session, there may be a specific 'logical time' at play. This time is dictated and defined by the person who has suffered violence, defined, quite literally and irreversibly, by the very minutes they arrive late.
I have previously explored (4) the unique nature of the discourse of those who have suffered violence, as well as the importance of not becoming ensnared in it, a risk that can arise from various counter-transference dynamics.
These might include: a shared gender identity with the victim; an alignment in emotional expression; a protective impulse, influenced by age proximity or distance, in the face of the 'unspeakability and unherdability' of the nature of the violence; feelings of guilt stemming from a shared gender identity with the perpetrator, often leading to a compensatory urge; or the projection of what is being heard onto one’s own children.
Maintaining a clear focus and perspective is essential for receiving and working with such demands of care; this requires particular attention to the specific form of discourse that emerges from individuals who have suffered violence.
The discourse of those who have experienced violence is often characterized by a two-dimensional quality, flattened, not only by the binary of 'victim and/or 'perpetrator', but also by a radical, destabilizing shift in the very concepts of good and evil.
The self presentation of an individual to a session in the capacity of a 'victim', it does not always mark a first step in the process toward emancipation. It might sounds paradoxical, but it might partly referred to social acceptance that the systemic nature of violence within a patriarchal society has finally been openly and emphatically acknowledged, and partly because the suffered violence has stripped the individual of their sense of self. In this case, 'being a victim' risks becoming a foundation for identity construction and recognition. It functions as a veritable "false self" which, through depersonalization (to be clear, a life-saving and harm-reduction fundamental defense to the stripping away of one's subjectivity) offers an identity that one can inhabit.
If, in an session, one of the two individuals identifies as 'the victim', this inevitably implies the presence of a 'perpetrator' standing opposite them, who serves to validate that very status.
The professional who receives a demand for treatment from someone who has suffered violence is the subject who implicitly confirms and certifies it from his own position: being in front of that of the person who has suffered, the therapist's position is implacably and inexorably pushed by the phantom of being in the place of the perpetrator (in loco carnificis).
This phantom is not always perceived as such by those who listen to the stories of violence, and, indeed, it can happen that it is underestimated or denied, even if it can be felt directly in to care-worker's body, due to the anger that arises just from being placed in this position.
The paradox with which we find ourselves extricating in is the almost necessity of this position as the first barrier to devouring anguish. If this did not happen, in fact, an even greater risk could materialize for the person who has suffered violence: an implosion into an even deeper anguish linked to "not even being" a victim.
In this sense, identification with the phantom is almost necessary, we could say, to start the treatment process. It is therefore essential for the listener to also be able to listen to this powerful component, which in turn activates a particular dialogic process.
For those who have suffered violence, the dimension of trauma risks, as we have already observed (5), becoming a defining feature of their identity. In this process, anguish completely overwhelms the symbolic realm, causing the logical categories of good and evil to shift, not merely into their opposites (as occurs, for instance, in certain forms of perversion), but into a synthesis that establishes an entirely new terrain, one that entails and constitutes itself as:
“…a radical shift and reversal between what is typically understood as good and what is understood as evil. A structural movement that, through an ‘overflowing,’ gives rise to two new forms: ‘Good-evil’ and ‘Evil-good.’ The former involves an intention to do good that spills over into the infliction of evil. The latter involves the infliction or reception of evil as if it were good. These are no longer two distinct categories, but rather an overflowing that progressively takes the form of a delusional sliding of one into the other, and vice versa.” (6)
The most complicated dimension is not the one relating to the statement that often returns in the initial part of the work and in much news, that is, "he hurt me but he loved me".
In the radical reversal and in the crasis between 'Good-evil' and the 'Evil-good', the most difficult component of the discourse to work with is the logical symmetrical equivalent: since "if it hurts me it's because it loves me", it follows that "to love me it must hurt me".
This discussion, the only one that allows survival in a situation of radical human and emotional, as well as physical, unsustainability, will also be reported in the field of dynamics with the therapist.
In receiving and inhabiting this space, it becomes essential to inhabit that position so well evoked at the beginning by Lacan's words: it is necessary to be "being up to the perspective of being a subject of being".
The fact that the person asks for treatment from the position of the victim, that is, of the person who is "the object of...", does not mean that he or she must be slavishly assumed as such.
As we know well, or should know well, the work of care entails bearing witness to, and interpreting, the process of subjectivization, regardless of the outcome. It is then up to the individual to make of this whatever they can. Whatever the result, it will inevitably mark at least a slight shift or deviation in the process of subjectivization.
In other words, it means occupying one’s own discursive register as an 'other' subject, who is, at the same time, an object within the subjectivization processes of the 'other' person: that is, the individual who brings a request for care.
What is required is a definition of discourse that serves as a testament to a structuring symbolic function, acting simultaneously as a witness to both a symbolic discursive possibility and a physical possibility of existence, which the person seeking care may then utilize as they see fit.
This is the profound meaning behind my repeated assertion that a true position of car derives its utility precisely from the awareness of our own essential uselessness.
Common sense, for what it’s worth, is not only mistaken; it risks becoming an obstacle, potentially creating common ground with the patient’s own defensive mechanisms.
It is often assumed that those who have lived through traumatic experiences are eager to seize any opportunity to change their situation. Nothing could be further from the truth.
John Bowlby addressed this when he spoke of the necessity of 'detachment': "…I have been in such pain," the child’s mind might say, "that I cannot re-establish contact… I cannot risk being hurt again…" (7)
Inevitably, a shift occurs, one that might appear paradoxical on the surface, but is not truly so. We witness a defensive movement that apparently works *against* overcoming the trauma, a position that is, at its core, desperately defensive. This, in turn, directly reflects the scale and magnitude of the trauma itself.
Whether we call it detachment (as in Bowlby’s terms) or resistance (in the Freudian sense), this movement does not signify a *lack of desire* to heal, but rather an unconscious expression of an *inability* to do so.
This position is mirrored in the therapist, triggering the very counter-transference dynamics mentioned earlier: shared gender; similar emotional expressions; a protective instinct in the face of the unspeakability and unheardability nature of violence (influenced by the age gap, or lack thereof, between therapist and patient); a vague sense of guilt stemming from sharing a gender with the perpetrator, often accompanied by a perceived need to 'make amends'; or, more simply, a subtle, narcissistic, and omnipotent desire to be the one who can heal the wounds of the sufferer, someone who brings with them the unspeakable abyss of the violence or torture they have suffered.
These counter-transference dimensions set in motion movements of emotional closeness. For those listening to the life-stories of survivors of violence, this requires a profound self-awareness, one that engages not only with one’s own most vulnerable aspects but also with those parts that have been most deeply wounded.
It means listening to the scars of our own wounds so that we may work from a position of truly open receptivity, creating unfilled and unsaturated spaces capable of holding the wounds of others, allowing those wounds to eventually close and become scars.
Giving voice and depth to emotional experiences, which often manifest as immediate, painful sensations, frequently internalized and felt within the body, is the crucial step that prevents the loss of one’s own essential subjectivity.
The goal is not merely to find ways to offload these experiences; rather, it is for each caregiver, in their own unique way, to discover a personal, individual capacity to imbue these experiences with meaning through language, as well as through emotional and bodily awareness. In doing so, one avoids becoming a prisoner to these experiences, and instead safeguards, by nurturing it, the freedom to resist in the face of violence, while remaining the true subject of one’s own life.
In this perspective, we can reiterate this, citing Lacan once more, by saying that one can rise to the level of the subject, agreeing to inhabit a space that is both physical and logical. In this space, one serves a structuring function, acting as an 'Other', that stands as both an occasional and a precise, embodied testimony to the process of subjectivation.
To put it another way: when faced with a person who has been displaced from their own position of subjectivation, stripped of the truth of their own identity, we can inhabit this arduous, painful, and at times despairing ground.
We do so by offering an embodied testimony to liberation, achieved through the act of putting experience into words, a process that allows for the gathering, cultivating, and nurturing of the possibility, articulated by Nietzsche, of 'becoming what one is.'
The care-process might lead to a concrete form, and sometimes does not.
Herein lies the stance of those who listen to life stories marked by suffered violence: it resides precisely in the utility of our own 'uselessness', a 'uselessness' that is the only condition that allows each individual to become what they might yet be.
…….
P.S.: my personal gratitude to the colleagues who, in various capacities, support the women in the 'Forzamamme' project, funded by Fondazione Specchio dei Tempi in Turin and Cuneo, as well as to the colleagues, volunteers, social workers and lawyers at the 'Non sei sola' (You Are Not Alone) Support Center for women victims of violence in Biella.
Some of these reflections stem from the work we shared.
...
1. F. Nietzsche, *Ecce Homo: How One Becomes What One Is*, 1888
2. P. Preciado, *I Am a Monster That Speaks to You*, 2020
3. J. Lacan, lecture at the Centre Hospitalier du Vintier in Lyon, 1967
4. and 5. Pensieri del dentro 9: parole rovesciate (“Thoughts from the inside 9: when words invert their meanings - the radical shift, or rather, the discourse of the victim and of the survivor) https://www.paolobrusa.it/2022/01/pensieri-del-dentro-9-parole-rovesciate.html (only in Italian at the moment, to be translated soon)
6. J. Bowlby, Attachment and Loss, Vol. 2: Separation: Anxiety and Anger, 1973



Comments
Post a Comment